American actress Claire Danes said that Manila is dirty and full of rats. We banned her movies and declared her a persona non grata. Teri Hatcher in the US series "Desperate Housewives" quipped about Filipino doctors with fake diplomas. We demanded apology and the deletion of the scene. British Broadcasting Company (BBC) aired in one of its channels a comedy show where a Filipina maid was coaxed to have sex with a British man. We demanded apology and asked for the deletion of the scene.
And now, a Hong Kong-Chinese wrote a satirical article in Hong Kong Magazine regarding the brewing territorial war between China and the Philippines over the Spratly Group of Islands. He wrote that the Philippines is a "nation of servants" (read the full article here).
We felt insulted and demanded an apology. The article was removed from the publisher's website while the publisher gave a non-apology apology:
"The publisher and editors of HK Magazine wish to apologize unreservedly for any offense that may have been caused by Chip Tsao's column dated March 27... One aspect of satire is that it can at times be read in different ways. In this particular case, many people have read meanings unto this column that were never actually intended." (read the complete apology here)
Here are the ironies highlighted by Mr. Tsao. First, his domestic helper is a graduate of University of Manila. In other countries, "University" plus name of capital is reserved for the leading or most prestigious university in the country. Like University of Tokyo or University of Paris. In the Philippines, University of Manila is not even included in the top-5 universities. Whether Mr. Tsao knows that or do not, I am not sure. But any casual observer can misinterpret that a graduate of University of Manila is among the country's best and brightest.
Second, her domestic helper has a college degree in International Politics. To clarify things, University of Manila does not offer International Politics, the closest they have is BA major in Political Science (according to wikipedia, their website is blank). The main issue is that a lot of Filipina domestic helpers in Hon Kong are college graduates. They may seem overqualified for the job but I am not really so sure. This highlights serious problems with our educational system and the availability of jobs for college graduates in the Philippines.
Third, the article highlights the sad state of our Navy and Military. I think the main point of the article is to mock the might (or lack of it) of our military. Mr. Tsao wrote "she would pay taxes to her government, and they would fund a navy to invade our motherland and deeply hurt my feelings."
While Filipinos all over the world have the right to feel offended and get angry at Mr. Tsao's article, there are several issues I have to raise.
First, newspapers and media reports wrongfully translated "nation of servants" into "bayan ng mga alipin." Alipin is translated into English as slave, a servant is literally translated as tagapag-silbi or katulong. I'll be offended if I was called a slave, but with servant, I am not sure. However, I remember that Congress already outlawed the use of the term "katulong" and we now call them "kasambahay" or "housemate". Will Mr. Tsao be considered less racist if he calls us a "nation of housemates"?
Second, whenever issues like these are raised with sign online petitions and demand apologies from the people who offended us. But we never look at ourselves and demand apology from our leaders and ourselves.
After we banned Claire Danes from our country and our cinemas, have we made Manila cleaner and less rat-infested?
After we got the producers of Desperate Housewives to delete that scene about Filipino doctors, have we forced Recto University out of business? We have cleansed our country of fake diplomas and transcripts of record?
After we got an apology from BBC, have we ensured that no Filipino will ever be subjected to human trafficking, illegal prostitution and/or abuse? Have we increased the level of protection for our Filipino workers regardless of occupation?
The answers are No, No, No, No and No. We should start demanding for an apology from our leaders for allowing us to become the butt of jokes around the world. After an apology, we should demand action so that this will never happen again. Not by censoring all the jokes and references to us, but by improving our conditions and sending the right signal to the world!
Now, regarding Mr. Tsao's alleged racism let me leave you lines from a song from Tony-Award winning musical Avenue Q:
Ethnic jokes might be uncouth,
But you laugh because
They're based on truth.
Don't take them as
Personal attacks.
Everyone enjoys them -
So relax!
If we all could just admit
That we are racist a little bit,
Even though we all know
That it's wrong,
Maybe it would help us
Get along.
Everyone's a little bit racist
It's true.
But everyone is just about
As racist as you!
If we all could just admit
That we are racist a little bit,
And everyone stopped being
So PC
Maybe we could live in -
Harmony!
HAPPY APRIL FOOLS DAY!!!!